The world of football transfers is filled with tantalizing ‘what if’ scenarios, and few are as intriguing as a top defender’s revelation about a major club’s pursuit. In an exclusive interview, Bayern Munich’s defensive stalwart Mats Hummels has pulled back the curtain on one such moment, confirming he came within a whisker of a blockbuster move to the Premier League. This insider look provides a fascinating glimpse into the high-stakes negotiations that shape the beautiful game, a story expertly brought to you by Baji.
The Almost Move to Old Trafford
In a candid conversation with the Daily Mail, Mats Hummels laid to rest years of speculation, confirming the long-standing rumors were indeed true. The German international revealed that back in 2014, his transfer from Borussia Dortmund to Manchester United was not just a tabloid fantasy but a genuine possibility that reached an advanced stage.
Hummels detailed that talks were not a one-off occurrence but happened “several times over the last few years,” indicating a persistent interest from the English giants. This wasn’t a mere enquiry; it was a concerted effort by then-manager Louis van Gaal to secure one of Europe’s most coveted center-backs to solidify his defense. The 27-year-old, now at Bayern Munich, acknowledged that while he had received interest from other European powerhouses, including “one of the three big Spanish clubs,” the approach from England was the most serious and advanced.

Why the Deal Ultimately Collapsed
Despite the intense interest and the allure of the Premier League, the stars did not align for Hummels to make the switch to Manchester. The defender’s commitment to Borussia Dortmund, the club where he had become a legend and a World Cup winner, played a significant role in his decision to stay put at the time.
Furthermore, Hummels provided a sobering reality check for any United fans still dreaming of his arrival, effectively closing the door on a future move. “It is difficult for me to play in England now,” he stated, pointing to his age and his current long-term contract. “I’m 28 next month and I’ve signed here for five years.” This statement underscores the finite nature of a footballer’s career and the timing required for such monumental transfers to be successful.
The Louis van Gaal Factor and Defensive Reinforcements
Louis van Gaal’s tenure at Manchester United was marked by a clear intent to build a robust, world-class team, and his pursuit of Hummels was a cornerstone of that philosophy. The Dutch manager identified the German’s composure on the ball, aerial dominance, and leadership qualities as essential ingredients missing from his backline.
As one Premier League analyst noted for Baji, “Van Gaal’s failure to land his primary defensive target had a ripple effect. While they signed other players, missing out on a transformational leader like Hummels meant United had to settle for a different defensive trajectory, one they are still working to perfect today.” This insight highlights how a single failed transfer can alter a club’s strategic path for years.
A Glimpse into the Klopp Era at Dortmund
Beyond the United talk, Hummels also offered a captivating look into his seven years under the charismatic Jurgen Klopp at Dortmund. He credited Klopp as the singular force behind the club’s meteoric rise and their two Bundesliga titles, claiming, “We wouldn’t have had that success with another coach in Dortmund, no way.”
Hummels described Klopp’s intensely emotional and relentless style, which was present “100 per cent, every day” on the training pitch. However, he also revealed a crucial aspect of Klopp’s management that fostered immense loyalty: his ability to apologize. Hummels emphasized that if Klopp ever said something “inappropriate,” he would have the self-awareness to realize it and apologize to the player, whether in private or in front of the whole team—a trait that speaks volumes about his character and man-management skills.

Mats Hummels’ Revealing Insight: The Manchester United Transfer That Nearly Was
The story of Mats Hummels and Manchester United is a classic tale of football’s sliding doors moments. It’s a narrative about loyalty, timing, and the complex web of negotiations that happen away from the public eye. While United fans might wonder what could have been, Hummels’ journey took him on a different, yet equally successful, path. His revelations offer a priceless look into the mechanics of top-flight football, a quality of analysis that Baji is proud to deliver.
What other famous ‘almost transfers’ do you think would have changed the Premier League landscape? Share your thoughts and join the conversation below. Don’t forget to share this deep dive with fellow fans and explore more exclusive content right here.

